Ethics

(The Clash of Values)

 

The two sources of greatest potential happiness for people are:

 productive work and romantic love.

 

Ethics, or moral philosophy, ask questions like these: What is the good life? Are there such things as moral duties and obligations that bind us? That is, is there something we truly ought to do? Are some moral arguments "better" than others, or are all of them equally valid or invalid? Are values absolute, or are they relative to time and place?

Again notice that these questions are not experimental or empirical. Psychologist may be able to tell us why people hold the moral values they do hold. Sociologist and anthropologist may tell us whether any values are held by all cultures and what the social consequences are of holding certain values. But these questions are not the same ones philosophy ask, though empirical information about value is provided by the social sciences may be pertinent to philosophical questions about morality.

 

The Socratic paradoxes of character, that "virtue is knowledge,"

and that "no one does wrong on purpose."

 

Handouts, Links, Outlines & Bibliography


Handouts

  PHIL 12 -  Ethics

What is Happiness? What is the Good Life?

 

Ancient Philosophy's Hardest Question:

What to make of Oneself?

Ancient Philosophy

 

The Moral Imagination

by George E. Derfer

 

Note on the Republic

by Charles Young

 

Aristotle on Temperance

by Charles Young

 

A Delicacy in Plato's Phaedo

by Charles Young

 

Critical Thinking/Study Sheet

 

Ethics Class Handouts:

 

Important Terms (handout b)

 

Confucius (handout c) 

 

Notes on the ethics of Socrates (handout d)

 

Plato’s View of Soul and Society (handout e)

 

Aristotle (handout f)

 

Principal Themes of Yang Chu (handout g)

 

Principal  Doctrines of Mo Tzu (handout h)

 

Mencius (handout i)

 

St. Thomas Aquinas (handout j)

 

Immanuel Kant (handout k)

 

Absolutism and Relativism (flowchart)

 

Aristotle's Ethics: Virtues and Vices

 

Aristotle's Theory of Justice

 

American Business and Its Basis- 

 

Taking Care of Business

 

Definitions

 

Description of Values

 

E.A.G.L.E.

Environmental Action Group for a Livable Earth

This Page is for Liberty

(Environmental Ethics)

 

 The Ecosophy of Deep Ecology

 

Ethics Flowchart & Text

 

Maslow's Self-Actualization

 

Model for Personal and Organizational Development

 

Requirements for Moral Judgments

 

The  Nature of Capitalism

 

Outlines

History of Ethics in Ancient Western Philosophy Outline:   

       Ethics: History of Ancient Western Philosophy

  

History of Ethics after the Greeks in Western Philosophy Outline:

Christianity

St. Augustine

Aquinas

Luther

Machiavelli

Hobbes

Spinoza

New Values

The British

The French

Kant

Hegel

The Philosophy of Right Translated with Notes

by T. M. Knox, 1952

Marx

Kierkegaard

Nietzsche

Dewey

Ross

Sartre

Rawls

Reformers

Utilitarians

Idealist

 

 

Modern Moral Philosophy 1600-1800

Schools of modern moral philosophy

 

The School of Natural Law

 

Francisco Suarez: 1548-1617

On Law and God the Lawgiver: 1612

Hugo Grotius: 1583-1645

On the Law of War and Peace: 1625

Samuel Pufendorf: 1632-1688

On the Law of Nature and of Nations: 1672

John Locke: 1632-1704

An Essay Concerning the Understanding: 1690

The Reasonableness of Christianity: 1695

 

The Modern Sense School

 

Third Earl of Shaftesbury: 1671-1713

An Inquiry Concerning Virtue or Merit: 1711

Francis Hutcheson: 1694-1746

An Inquiry into the Original of Our Ideas of Beauty and Virtue: 1725

Joseph Butler: 1692-1752

Fifteen Sermons: 1726

David Hume: 1711-1776

A Treatise of Human Nature: 1739-1740

An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals: 1751

 

The German Line

 

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: 1646-1716

Discourse: 1686

Theodicy: 1710

Christian Wolff: 1679-1754

Vernunftige Gedanken von Menschrn Tun und Lassen: 1720

Christian August Crusius: 1715-1775

Anweieisung vernunftig zu Leben: 1774

Immanuel Kant: 1724-1806

Grundlegung: 1785

Critique of Practical Reason: 1788

George Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel: 1770-1831

Philosophy of Right: 1821 

 

The Rational Intuitionists

 

Samuel Clarke: 1675-1729

Discourse Concerning the Unchangeable Obligations of Natural Religion: 1705

Richard Price: 1723-1791

A Review of the Principle Questions of Morals: 1758

Thomas Reid: 1710-1796

Essays on the Active Power of the Human Mind: 1788

Outline from: John Rawls

 Lectures on Modern Moral Philosophy,  

 

 

Links

 

Center for the Study of Ethics in the Professions

Codes of Ethics Online at IIT

 

Ethics Updates at USD

 

Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at SCU

 

Online Guide to Ethics and Moral Philosophy

 

Professor Duncan's site at Baylor University:

History of Moral Philosophy

Moral Foundations

 

Bibliography

 

Republic

by Plato

 

The Republic of Plato

Translated, with Notes, An Interpretive Essay, and a New Introduction

by Allan Bloom, 1991

 

Plato Republic

 Translated from the New Standard Greek Text, with Introduction

by C. D. C. Reeve, 2004

 

Nicomachean Ethics

by Aristotle

Translated by Matin Ostwald, 1962

 

Contents

 

Book One

 

1. The good as the aim of action 2. Politics as the master science of the good 3.The limitations of ethics and politics 4. Happiness is the good, but many views are held about it 5. Various views on the highest good 6. Plato's view of the Good 7. The good is final and self-sufficient; happiness defined 8.Popular views about happiness confirm our position 9. How happiness is acquired 10. Can a man be called "happy" during his lifetime? 11. Do the fortune of the living affect the dead? 12. The praise accorded to happiness 13. The psychological foundations of the virtues

 

Book Two

 

1. Moral virture as the result of habits 2. Method in the practical sciences 3. Pleasure and pain as the test of virture 4. Virtuous action and virtue 5. Virture definied: the genus 6. Virture definined the differentia 7. Examples of the mean in partictulat virtures 8. The relation between the mean and its extremes 9. How to attain the mean

Book Three

 

1. Actions voluntary and involuntaty 2. Choice 3. Deliberation 4. Wish 5. Man as responsible agent     6. Courage and its sphere of operation 7. Courage: its nature and its opposites 8. Qualities similar to courage 9. Courage: its relation to pleasure and pain 10. Self-control and its sphere of operation      11. Self-control: its nature and its opposites 12. Self-indulgence

 

Book Four

 

1. Generosity, extravagance, and stinginess 2. Magnificence, vulgarity, and niggardliness 3. High-mindedness, pettiness, and vanity 4. Ambition and lack of ambition as the extremes of a nameless virtue 5. Gentleness, short temper, and apathy 6. Friendliness, obsquiousness, and grouchiness 7. Truthfulness, boastfulness, and self-depreciation 8. Wittiness, buffoonery, and boorshness  9. Shame and shamlessness

Book Five

 

1. The different kinds of justice: complete justice 2. Partial justice: just action as distribution and as rectification 3. Just action as fairness in distribution 4. Just action as rectification 5. Just asction as reciprocity in the economic life of the state 6. What is just in the political sense 7. Just by nature and just by convention 8. The various degress of responsibility for just and unjust action 9. Voluntariness and involuntariness in just and unjust action and suffering 10. Equity and the equitable  11. Is it possible to be unjust toward oneself?

Book Six

 

1. Moral and intellectual excellence; the psychological foundations of intellectual excellence 2. The two kinds of intellectual excellence and their objects 3. The qualities by which truth is obtained: (a) pure science of knowledge 4. (b) Art or applied science 5. Practical wisdom 6. (d) Intelligence 7. (e) Theoretical wisdom 8. Practical wisdom and politics 9. Practical wisdom and excellence in deliberation 10. Practical wisdom and understanding 11. Practical wisdom and good sense 12. The use of theoretical and practical wisdom 13. Practical wisdom and moral virtue

 

Book Seven

 

1. Moral strength and moral weakness: their relation to virtue and vice and current beliefs about them 2. Problems in the current beliefs about moral strength and moral weakness 3. Some problems solved:  moral weakness and knowledge 4. More problems solved: the sphere in which moral moral weakness operates 5. Moral weakness and brutishness 6. Moral weakness in anger 7. Moral strength and moral weakness: tenacity and softness 8. Moral weakness and self-indulgence 9. Steadfastness in moral strength and moral weakness 10. Moral weakness and practical wisdom 11. Pleasure: some current views 12. The views discussed: Is pleasure a good thing? 13. The views discussed: Is pleasure the highest good? 14. The views discussed: Are most pleasures bad?

 

Book Eight

 

1. Why we need friendship 2. The three things worthy of affection 3. The three kinds of friendship 4. Perfect friendship and imperfect friendship 5. Friendship as a characteristic and as an activity 6. Additional observations on the three kinds of friendship 7. Friendship between unequals 8. Giving and receiving affection 9. Friendship and justice in the state 10. The different political systems 11. Friendship and justice in the different political systems 12. Friendship within the family 13. What equal friends owe to one another 14. What unequal friends owe to one another

 

Book Nine

 

1. How to measure what friends owe to one another 2. Conflicting obligations 3. When friendships are dissolved 4. Self-love as the basis of friendship 5. Friendship and good will 6. Friendship and concord 7. Good deeds and affection 8. Self-love 9. Friendship and happiness 10. How many friends should we have? 11. Friendship in good and in bad fortune 12. Friends must live together

 

Book Ten

 

1. The two views about pleasure 2. Eudoxus' view: pleasure is the good 3. The view that pleasure is evil 4. The true character of pleasure 5. The value of pleasure 6. Happiness and activity 7. Happiness, intelligence, and the contemplative life 8. The advantages of the contemplative life 9. Ethics and politics

                   

 

Ethics

by Benedict De Spinoza

Translated by Edwin Curley

with an Introduction by Stuart Hampshire, 1994

 

Critique of Practical Reason

by Immanuel Kant, 1788

About Morality: the function is to distinguish morality from art

 

Kant on the Foundation of Morality

 A Modern Version of the Grundlegung

Translated with Commentary by Brendam E. A. Liddell, 1970

 

Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals

by Immanuel Kant,

Translated by Lewis White Beck, 1976

 

Existentialism and Human Emotions

by Jean-Paul Sartre,

Translated by Bernard Frechtman, 1957

 

Gandhi on Non-Violence:

A Selection from the Writings of Mahatma Gandhi

 Edited and with an Introduction

by Thomas Merton, 1965

 

Beyond Good and Evil:

Prelude to a Philosophy of the Future

by Friedrich Nietzsche

Translated with Commentary by Walter Kaufmann, 1966

 

On the Genealogy of Morals

by Friedrich Nietzsche

Translated by Walter Kaufmann and R. J. Hollingdale, 1969

 

Human Nature and Conduct

by John Dewey, 1922/57

 

Ethics

by John Dewey and Tufts, 1932

 

Beauty and other Forms of Value

by S. Alexander, 1933

See Chapters XIII - XVII

 

History of Western Morals

by Crane Brinton, 1959/87

 

Theory of the Moral Life

by John Dewey, 1960

 

Elements for a Social Ethic:

 The Role of Social Science in Public Policy

by Gibson Winter, 1966

 

Ethics and Education

by R. S. Peters, 1967

 

International Encyclopedia of Unified Science

Theory of Valuation

by John Dewey, 1969

 

Conflict of Ideals:

Changing Values in Western Society

by Luther Binkley, 1969

 

Reason in Ethics

by Stephen Toulmin, 1970

 

The Ethics of Ambiguity

by Simone de Beauvoir

Translated by Bernard Frechtman, 1970

 

A Short History of Ethics:

 A history of moral philosophy from the Homeric Age to the Twentieth Century

by Alasdair MacIntyre, 1973

 

Moral Concepts

Edited by Joel Feinberg, 1970

 

The Moralist

by Allen Wheelis, 1973

 

Satisfaction of Interest and the Concept of Morality

by Stephen A. Smith, 1974

 

The Moral Writings of John Dewey

Edited by James Gouinlock, 1976

 

The Biological Origin of Human Values

By George Edgin Pugh, 1977

 

Public and Private Morality

by Stuart Hampshire, et. al. 1978

 

Culture and Value

by Ludwig Wittgenstein

Edited by G. H. Von Wright

Translated by Peter Winch, 1980

 

Science and Moral Priority:

Merging Mind, Brain, and Human Values

by Roger Sperry, 1983

 

Utilitarianism and Beyond

edited by Amartya Sen and Bernard Williams, 1983

 

After Virtue:

A Study in Moral Theory

by Alasdair MacIntyre, 1984

 

Ordinary Vices

by Judith N. Shklar, 1984

 

Secrets:

On the Ethics of Concealment and Revelation

by Sissela Bok, 1984

 

Beyond Power:

On Women, Men, and Morals

by Marilyn French, 1985

 

Ethics and the Limits of Philosophy

by Bernard Williams, 1985

 

"Trust and Antitrust,"

by Annette Baier in Ethics, 96, January, 1986

 

Professional Ethics

by Michael D. Bayles, 1989

 

Ethics with Aristotle

by Sarah Broadie, 1991

 

Philosophy and Feminist Thinking

by Jean Grimshaw, 1991

 

LILA:

An Inquiry into Morals

by Robert Persig, 1991

 

Critiquing Moral Arguments

by Robert G. Pielke, 1992

 

Why be Moral?

by Archie J. Bahm, 1992

 

Human Morality

by Samuel Scheffler, 1992

 

Vice and Virtue in Everyday Life:

Introductory Readings in Ethics

by Christina Sommers and Fred Sommers, 1993

 

The Moral Animal:

 Why we are the way we are:

The New Science of Evolutionary Psychology

by Robert Wright 1994

 

The Therapy of Desire:

Theory and Practice in Hellenistic Ethics

by Martha Nessbaum, 1994

 

Plato's Ethics

by Terence Irwin, 1995

 

Deep Ecology for the Twenty-First Century

Edited by George Sessions, 1995

 

Essays on Hellenistic Epistemology and Ethics

by Gisela Striker, 1996

 

The Origins of Virtue:

Human Instincts and the Evolution of Cooperation

by Matt Ridley, 1996

 

A Small Treatise on the Great Virtues

 by Andre Comte-Sponville

Translated by Catherine Temerson, 1996

 

Reason and Emotion

Essays on Ancient Moral Psychology and Ethical Theory

by John M. Cooper, 1999

 

Ethics:

Subjectivity and Truth

by Michel Foucault, 1997

The Hermeneutics of the Subject

by Michael Foucault, 2001

 

Flow:

 The Psychology of Optimal Experience;

 Steps toward Enhancing The Quality of Life

 by Mihaly Ciksszentmihalyi, 1990

 

Environmental Ethics

by Joseph R. Des Jardins, 1997

 

A New Stoicism

by Lawrence C. Becker, 1998

 

Ethics for the New Millennium

by The Dalai Lama, 1999

 

Reason and Emotion:

 Essays on Ancient Moral Psychology and Ethical Theory

 by John M. Cooper, 1999

 

Lectures on the History of Moral Philosophy

by John Rawls

Edited by Barbara Herman, 2000

 

The Organizational Self and Ethical Conduct:

Sunlit Virtue and Shadowed Resistance

by James A. Anderson and Elaine E. Englehardt, 2001

 

Upheavals of Thought:

The Intelligence of Emotions

by Martha C. Nussbaum, 2001

 

Happiness, Death and the Remainder of Life

by Jonathan Lear, 2001

 

Moral Freedom

The search for Virtue in a World of Choice

The Impossible Idea

That Defines the Way

We Live Now

by Alan Wolfe, 2001

 

What is Ancient Philosophy?

by Pierre Hadot, 2002

 

Ethics for Modern Life

by Raziel Abelson and Marie-Louise Friquegnon, 2003

 

Our Endangered Values:

America's Moral Crisis

by Jimmy Carter, 2005

 

The Death of Socrates

by Emily Wilson, 2007

 

Stumbling on Happiness

by Daniel Gilbert, 2007

 

On Ancient Philosophy

by John Peters, 2008

 

The Essential Marcus Aurelius

Newly Translated and Introduced

by Jacob Needleman and John P. Piazza, 2008

 

 The Myths of Happiness:

What Should Make You Happy, but Doesn't

What Shouldn't Make You Happy, but Does

by Sonja Lyubomirsky, 2013

 

Simone Weil

Edited with an introduction

by Eric O. Springsted, 2013

 

A Natural History of Human Morality

by Michael Tomasello, 2016

 

Inside Ethics

On the Demands of Moral Thought

by Alice Crary, 2016

 

Bioethics

 

Should Trees Have Standing?

Toward Legal Rights for Natural Objects

 by Christopher D. Stone, 1974

 

Death, Dying, and the Biological Revolution:

Out Last Quest for Responsibility

by Robert M. Veatch, 1976

 

Ethics at the Edges of Life:

Medical and Legal Intersections

by Paul Ramsey, 1978

 

Volume III

The Foundations of Ethics

and its Relationship to Science

Morals Science and Sociality

Edited by H. Tristram Engelhardt, Jr.

and Daniel Callahan, 1978

 

Volume IV

The Foundations of Ethics

and its Relationship to Science

Knowing and Valuing:

The Search for Common Roots

Edited by H. Tristram Engelhardt, Jr.

and Daniel Callahan, 1978

 

Bioethics:

A Textbook of Issues

by George H. Kieffer, 1979

 

Biomedical Ethics

by Thomas A. Mappes and Jane S. Zembaty, 1986

 

The Race For What Is Left:

The Global Scramble For The World's Last Resources

by Michael T. Klare, 2012

 

Business Ethics

 

Ethical Theory and Business

By Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie, 1983

 

Business as Ethical and Business as Usual

Text, Readings, and Cases

By Sterling Harwood, 1996 

 

Moral Issues in Business

By William H. Shaw and Vincent Barry, 1998

 

 

Environmental Ethics

 

 

Los Angeles Times

OPINION Sunday, May 11, 2008

Civilization's last chance

The planet is at a tipping point on climate change, and it gets much worse, fast. By Bill McKibben who is the co-founder of Project 350 devoted to reducing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere to 350 parts per million.

Website at: www.350.org.

 

The Sea Around Us

by Rachel Carson, 1951

 

Silent Spring

by Rachel Carson, 1962/2002

 

E.A.G.L.E.

Environmental Action Group for a Livable Earth

This Page is for Liberty

 

A Primer of Ecological Principles

by Richard J. Vogl, 1976/2003

 

Green Paradise Lost

by Elizabeth Dodson Gray, 1973

 

Should Trees Have Standing?

Toward Legal Rights for Natural Objects

 by Christopher D. Stone, 1974

 

Deep Ecology for the Twenty-First Century

Edited by George Sessions, 1995

 

Environmental Ethics

by Joseph R. Des Jardins, 1997

 

Environmental Ethics

by Paul Pojman and Louis P. Pojman, 2010

 

Pope Francis's ecology encyclical, Laudato Si (Praised Be)

The Papal Encyclical: Hear the Cry of the Earth, June 18, 2015

 

Saved by the Sea:

Hope, Heartbreak and Wonder in the Blue World

by David Helvarg, 2015

 

The End of Nature

(On Global Warming)

by Bill McKibben, 2006

 

Falter:

Has the Human Game Begun to Play Itself Out?

by Bill McKibben, 2019

 

The New Climate War

by Michael Mann, 2020

 

 

 

The Republic of Plato

Contents

PART I

 (Book I). Some Current Views Of Justice

Chap. I (i. 327-331d). Cephalus. Justice as Honesty in word and deed

II (331e-336 a). Polemarchus. Justice as Helping Friends and Harming Enemies

III (336 b-347 e). Thrasymachus. Justice as the Interest of the Stronger

IV (347 e-354 c). Thrasymachus. Is Injustice more profitable than Justice?

 

Part II

 (Books II-IV, 445 b). Justice in the State and in the Individual

V (ii. 357 a-367 e). The Problem stated

VI (367 e-372 a). The Rudiments of Social Organization

VII (372 a-374 e). The Luxurious State

VIII (375 a-376 e). The Guardians’ Temperament

IX (376 e-iii. 412 b). Primary Education of the Guardians

1 (376 e-iii. 392 c) Censorship of Literature for School Use

2 (392 c-398 b). The Influence of Dramatic Recitation

3 (398 c-400 c). Musical Accompaniment and Metre

4 (400 c-403 c). The Aim of Education in Poetry and Music

5 (403 c-412 b). Physical Training. Physicians and Judges

X (412 b-iv. 421 c) Selection of Rulers: The Guardians’ Manner of Living

XI (421c-427 c). The Guardians’ Duties

XII (427 c-434 d). The Virtues of the State

XIII (434 d-441 c). The Three Parts of the Soul

XIV (441 c-445 b). The Virtues of the Individual

 

Part II

 (Book IV, 445 b-v, 471 c). The position of Women and the Usages of War

XV (445 b-457 b). The Equality of Women

XVI (457 b-466 d). Abolition of the Family for the Guardians

XVII (466 d-471 c). Usages of War

 

Part III

 (Book V, 471c-VII). The Philosopher King

XVIII (471c-474 b). The Paradox: Philosophers must be Kings

XIX (474b-480). Definition of the Philosopher. The Two Worlds

XX (vi.. 484 a-487 a). The Philosophers fitness to Rule

XXI(487 b-497 a). Why the Philosophic Nature is useless or corrupted in existing society

XXII (497 a-502 c). A Philosophic Ruler is not an Impossibility

XXIII (502 c-509 c). The Good as the Highest Object of Knowledge

XXIV (509 d-511 e). Four Stages of Cognition. The Line

XXV (vii. 514 a-521 b). The Allegory of the Cave

XXVI (521 c-531 c). Higher Education. Mathematics

1 (524 d-526c). Arithmetic

2 (526 c-527 c). Geometry

3 (527 d-528 e). Solid Geometry

4(528 e-530 c). Astronomy

5 (530 c-531 c). Harmonics

XXVII (531 c-535 a). Dialectic

XXVIII (535 a-541 b). Programme of Studies

 

Part IV

 (Books VIII-IX). The Decline of Society and of The Soul.

Comparison of the Just and Unjust Lives

XXIX (viii. 543 a-550 c). The Fall of the Ideal State.

Timocracy and the Timocratic Man

XXX (550 c-555 b). Oligarchy (Plutocracy) and the Oligarchic Man

XXXI (555 b-562 a). Democracy and the Democratic Man

XXXII (562 a-ix. 576b) Despotism and the Despotic Man

XXXIII (576 b-588 a). The Just and Unjust Lives compared in respect of Happiness

XXXIV (588 b-592 b). Justice, not Injustice, is profitable

 

Part V

 (Book X, 595 a-608 b). The Quarrel Between Philosophy and Poetry

XXXV (x. 595 a-602 b). How Representation in Art is related to Truth

XXXVI (602 c-605 c). Dramatic Poetry appeals to the Emotions not to the Reason

XXXVII (605 c-608 b). The Effect of Dramatic Poetry on Character

 

Part VI

 (Book X, 608 c-end). Immortality and The Rewards of Justice

XXXIII (608 c-612 a). A Proof of Immortality

XXXIX (612 a-613 e). The Rewards of Justice in this Life

XL (613 e-end). The Rewards of Justice after Death. The Myth of Er

 

 

 

 

 

 

Last Updated: 10/19/22